State Police Must Be Earned, Not Handed Over

The constitutional fight is won on State Police in Nigeria. The real one is over a law nobody has written yet, which is, the rules a state must meet before its police can carry arms. Nigeria has already tried two ways of handing power to the states. Only one of them worked. In this piece, I argue that if a state must have its own Police, it must accept an independent commission responsible for oversight and certification, and be accountable for monies meant for it state policing.

On 30 September 2025, gunfire in Akinlalu, a farming town in Ife North, left residents dead. The police said their investigation pointed to Osun’s own Amotekun corps. A team from Force Headquarters in Abuja then arrested about 25 operatives and sealed the corps’ offices. One of the town’s chiefs, the Aro of Akinlalu, lost two of his children. Months later, Governor Ademola Adeleke was complaining of fresh kidnappings and of operatives held without trial, and civil society groups were still asking for the offices to reopen in December.

Akinlalu is the state police debate in one town. A state force was accused of killing the people it guards. A federal force answered by shutting the whole outfit down. Nobody in between could weigh the evidence and fix the problem without taking sides.

That missing referee is now the most important thing in Nigerian security policy. All 36 state assemblies have approved the constitutional amendment, and President Tinubu received the bill on 18 November. But the amendment does not switch anything on. Under the version the Senate passed, no state police service may begin operations until it is certified as meeting “national minimum standards”, set by an Act of the National Assembly. The Senate itself has asked the President to send a National Policing Bill to supply that framework. Whoever writes those standards decides what state police becomes. Nigeria’s own recent experiments in electricity and council funding show how to write them.

What the local government taught us

On 11 July 2024, the Supreme Court ruled that council allocations must go to elected councils, not to state governments. It was a clean legal victory. Yet Daily Trust found that 11 months later more than ₦3.4 trillion meant for councils had still passed through state-controlled joint accounts, and New Telegraph reported that governors kept their hold on council money into 2026.

The deeper problem is who runs council elections. Governors appoint the state electoral commissions, and the results look the same whatever the party. In Kaduna, the APC won all 23 chairmanships and all 255 councillor seats. In Anambra, APGA won every seat in all 21 councils. In Taraba, the PDP won every seat, unopposed. This is not one party’s vice. It is what happens when power is handed over in law while the appointments that control it stay with one office.

What electricity taught us

The Electricity Act 2023 took a different route. States won the right to regulate their own power markets, but the federal regulator, NERC, transfers oversight only to states that meet set conditions and build a working regulator. Fifteen states have now made that transition, starting with Enugu, Ekiti and Ondo in October 2024. Meanwhile NERC keeps regulating the states that are not yet ready, along with everything that crosses state lines.

It is too early to say whether state regulators will give Nigerians steadier light, and this essay does not claim they will. The point is the method. Power moved to states that proved they could use it, at their own pace, and nobody was left without a regulator in the meantime.

What the standards should test

The danger is that “minimum standards” becomes a checklist of uniforms, vehicles and recruits. Those matter, but Akinlalu was not a shortage of rifles. It was a shortage of independence. The Policing Bill should make certification depend on three tests.

First, an independent state police service commission. The bill already requires that a governor’s choice of commissioner be confirmed by the State Assembly, and that removal need a two-thirds vote. The Act should go further, and state that no governor should appoint or sack a majority of the body that hires, promotes and disciplines officers. The council elections show what happens when one office controls the referee.

Second, money the governor cannot divert. Governors have warned that a proposed 3 per cent of federation revenue for state police cannot even pay salaries. They may be right, so the funding question must be settled before certification, not after. Whatever the sum, it should sit in a dedicated account with published spending, not in a joint account of the kind that swallowed local council allocations.

Third, certification that can be reviewed. A state should renew its certificate every few years. Credible evidence of partisan use should trigger a published inquiry and, if proved, suspension. That is better than what Osun got, in which offices were sealed on Abuja’s word, with no public report and no clear end date.

The governors’ best case

The strongest objection comes from governors who have waited long enough. Oyo’s Seyi Makinde says Amotekun was only ever a stopgap for the state police the federal government would not allow, and that state assemblies, not the Inspector-General, should set it up. Ogun’s Dapo Abiodun says his state already has more than 6,000 Amotekun and So-Safe personnel ready. To them, certification sounds like a new way for Abuja to say no. Governors have warned privately that a federal-dominated council could starve a hostile state of equipment.

That fear is reasonable, and the answer is to borrow electricity’s discipline. The standards should be published, objective and time-bound. A state that meets them should be certified within a fixed period, with a right to go to court if it is refused. That protects Oyo from Abuja. The independence tests protect Akinlalu from Osogbo, and they answer the opposite fear too. For example, Borno’s Babagana Zulum opposed state police because some governors might use it against other ethnic groups.

We have seen local policing captured before. Northern Native Authority police were used against the opposition NEPU in the 1950s and 1960s, and a 1967 federal working party found the local forces poorly trained, corrupt and partisan. They were abolished in 1968. Their fault was not that they were local. It was that they answered to whoever held power.

If you want State Police, Earn it

Nigeria has handed over local government by decree and watched governors keep them. It has handed over electricity by stages and watched states build. State police is far more dangerous to get wrong than either, because it carries guns.

Fela Anikulapo-Kuti’s “Zombie” (1976) mocked soldiers who move only on command, and the military’s reply was to burn down his Kalakuta Republic. Scholars note the song’s real target is obedience without thought, wherever it is found, which is exactly the danger with any force that serves whoever appoints it.

The National Assembly should pass a Policing Bill that makes every state earn its police, including, an independent commission, money that cannot be diverted, and a certificate that can be taken back. Get those rules right, and the next Akinlalu will have a referee.

Sources

Status of the bill

Akinlalu, Osun

Local government autonomy

Electricity

Positions in the debate

History

Music